MOMENTS OF REFUGE FOR ISRAEL: THE SHARED HEALING PROJECT
I. HOW WILL ISRAEL RECOVER AND HEAL?
Unprecedented Collective Trauma. The tragedy and ongoing crisis of October 7, 2023 has affected every home and every resident of the country and, thereby, their families, friends and allies around the world. Millions of Israelis have experienced a collective trauma and loss, made worse by ongoing existential threat and uncertainty.
A Mental Health Crisis. Consequently, a mental health crisis is fast emerging, with unprecedent incidence of PTSD, depression, anxiety, and suicidality, and their destructive consequences for Israeli families and children. It is estimated that this is the single largest public mental health crisis in the history of the State of Israel and among the Jewish community since the Holocaust.
Social Radicalization. Worse yet, we also know that human-made collective trauma, particularly when tied to a national, ethnic and religious conflict, will amplify social radicalization, polarization and inter-cultural conflict. These dynamics threaten the future stability of Israeli civil society and any hope for an inclusive shared society. Beyond the initial national humanitarian crisis, the longer-term process of recovery and healing must be addressed effectively.
The Treatment Gap. Unfortunately, the mental health workforce in Israel was very small, under-funded, and unable to effectively address the national mental health burden, even before the crisis. Consequently, an unprecedented number of people will need care, but will not be able to access it, when and where they need it. There is a national imperative to develop a scalable portfolio of evidence-based therapeutic programs with reach and access across Israel and its social sectors. This is where we can be of help.
II. THE MOMENTS OF REFUGE PROJECT: HOPE IN INNOVATION
Our Mission. For over a decade, my group has conducted research to discover and develop therapeutic methods to promote recovery and healing among survivors of individual and collective trauma, loss, and existential uncertainty. Our work and findings led to the Moments of Refuge Project – a global social impact- and research- initiative to empower survivors of conflict, trauma and forced displacement, to heal and thrive. The initiative is a uniquely Israeli innovation – motivated by our ethical obligation to care for diverse communities locally and globally, who much like our own ancestors, now struggle with collective trauma, uncertainty and forced displacement. Thus, following the tragedy of October 7 and the war and uncertainty in its wake, we are now launching Moments of Refuge for Israel.
Mindfulness & Compassion as a Tool. There is strong evidence that to access our innate capacity to heal and recover from trauma and loss, we need to experience a subjective sense of refuge and safety within our lived experience. Objective safety is crucial, but not sufficient. This is why mindfulness- and compassion-based mental training is central to the Moments of Refuge mission and approach. Mindfulness meditation practices are designed to empower and enable people to experience moments of refuge and safety and, thereby, facilitate our innate capacity to adapt, to heal and to recover.
Moreover, in the past decade, a large scientific evidence-base has demonstrated the therapeutic stress-buffering effects of mindfulness and compassion training, therapeutic effects that are equivalent to much more intensive, costly and less scalable psychotherapeutic and pharmacological interventions. Our own randomized clinical trial research has documented that mindfulness- and compassion-based training is safe and effective, even among highly vulnerable trauma survivors facing adversity, injustice and uncertainty.
Finally, mindfulness training has broad reach and access, can be delivered to groups of participants and flexibly via digital platforms, is relatively low-cost, and its benefits can be sustained over time within and by communities. This scalability is critical to getting effective science-based care to those that need it, when and where they need it, even in complex and uncertain conflict-affected and post-displacement settings – much like Israel today.
Science as a Tool. Our approach to the implementation of Moments of Refuge is also unique because we use science as a tool to most effectively and responsibly implement our intervention programs. What this means, practically, is that we not only deliver therapeutic programs, but we use scientific monitoring and evaluation methods to ensure the ongoing intervention programs’ safety, therapeutic efficacy and impact, individual personalization of care, and ongoing therapeutic innovation and development. In the dynamic and unprecedented context of the mental health crisis in Israel post-October 7, we believe that our approach is now not only optimal clinically but is necessary ethically.
III. MOMENTS OF REFUGE FOR ISRAEL: OUR PLAN
National Reach Through a Hybrid Digital Platform + Group Support. The Moments of Refuge for Israel program will be delivered through our online digital mobile health program, in Hebrew, Arabic, and English. This ensures broad reach and access, utilization flexibility, and geographic mobility for displaced Israelis, with an unlimited capacity for scaling-up. For the many Israelis who will be in need of greater support and clinical personalization, our digital mobile Mindfulness-SOS program will be supported by community-embedded instructor-led groups, in-person or by zoom. This hybrid in-person group-supported intervention format also provides participants with greater access to connecting and recovering, together with a group of community peers. Groups will be led by trained and certified mindfulness instructors with clinical experience in trauma and mental health.
The Mindfulness-SOS Intervention Program. Mindfulness-SOS entails 8 brief training session modules and 10 complementary meditation practice exercises), that participants can flexibly access whenever and as frequently as they need. The hybrid in-person group-supported intervention format includes eight weekly 60-90-minute sessions (10-15 participants/group), designed to support the Mindfulness-SOS digital training session modules and meditation practice exercises. The intervention program entails trauma-sensitive, formal and informal mindfulness meditation and compassion practices, supported by psychoeducation on stress and trauma (e.g. to normalize, de-stigmatize) and socio-culturally inclusive communication of intervention principles and practices to diverse communities (e.g. metaphors, idioms).
IV. PHASED & PARTNER-BASED IMPLEMENTATION: THE NUTS & BOLTS
National Multi-Site Open-Trial. Aligned with our scientific approach to intervention program implementation, Mindfulness-SOS will be implemented through a multi-site open clinical trial, among Hebrew- and Arabic-speaking adults. To do this, we will partner with a network of mindfulness instructors and mental health service organizations across Israel.
Phase I: Multi-Site Pilot Implementation. Initial implementation will involve 1-2 training workshops delivered to 10 instructors, who will then implement the program in 10 pilot sites across Israel. To those in need of less support, Phase I will also offer Mindfulness-SOS without the additional instructor-led groups.
Phase II. Initial Scaling-Up. The second phase of the project will focus on initial scaling-up of implementation via recruitment and training of 10-20 additional group instructors. At Phase II, program capacity could reach and impact 930 or more participants every ~8-10 weeks (i.e. 20-30 instructors, each delivering ~3 groups/week, to 10-15 participants/group).
Phase III. Scaling to Sustainability. Depending on the scale of need in Israel and in mental health care service systems in the many months to come, it is likely that there will be further scaling-up of program implementation – e.g. additional training workshops, additional instructors, additional groups. Within 3 years, we expect that our partner mental health care organizations will have the capacity to implement the programs independently from our core Moments of Refuge for Israel team.
Monitoring and Evaluation: Impact Goals & Outcomes. Using our established digital measurement platform, we will systematically evaluate, quantify and optimize program delivery and its therapeutic impact on trauma- and stress-related mental health symptoms of program participants as well as on their family members and children; empirically identify individuals who need additional mental health care or other services; and thereby generate a novel therapeutic capacity as well as empirical evidence-base to share with mental health care providers in Israel and around the world.
Outcome metrics include improved capacity to cope with the trauma and stress following October 7, reduced rates and severity of trauma- and stress-related symptoms (e.g. PTSD, depression, anxiety, suicidality), and thereby, improved family and child outcomes. By impacting thousands of Israelis, the program will also contribute to collective social resilience as well as help buffer social radicalization and polarization within their respective social networks and communities around the country.
V. BUDGET NARRATIVE
We are now seeking support of $500,000 to launch year one of our project. Funding is needed primarily to support team personnel, including a national project coordinator, clinical care and training coordinator, community partnership coordinator, a software programmer, intervention group leaders, monitoring and evaluation support staff, and logistical expenses. Additional personnel resources from our team, including from Prof. Amit Bernstein, will be provided in kind. We foresee that Moments of Refuge for Israel will be needed, for at least, the next 3 years. If you are interested and would like to discuss how you may join and support us, please contact Professor Amit Bernstein: abernstein@psy.haifa.ac.il
Amit Bernstein
Professor, University of Haifa, School of Psychological Sciences
Visiting Professor, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Dept. of Psychology, Center for Healthy Minds
Director, Observing Minds Lab & The Moments of Refuge Project
Email: abernstein@psy.haifa.ac.il / USA Phone: +1-608-690-0154 / Israel Whatsapp: +972-54-263-4378
Professor Bernstein is the Director of the Observing Minds Lab and the Moments of Refuge Project, in the School of Psychological Sciences at the University of Haifa. Prof. Bernstein is an alumnus of the Israel Young Academy of the Israel National Academy of Sciences and Humanities and, currently, a Visiting Professor at the Center for Healthy Minds at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. With his students and colleagues, Prof. Bernstein has published over 160 scientific articles guided by his commitment to compassionate, rigorous and ambitious clinical science with a restorative social impact mission.
University of Haifa
The University of Haifa (UH) is the most diverse research institution of higher education in Israel. Home to more than 17,000 students (including IDF officers and security personnel) and faculty members from different ethnic, religious, and socioeconomic backgrounds, the University brings Jews, Muslims, Christians, Druze together in the pursuit of knowledge, to engage with each other in a local setting to solve global problems. UH serves as a model of tolerance and coexistence in Israel, strengthening society by expanding academic opportunities for all and building a new Israeli middle class. The university’s unique ecosystem - on the mountain, in the city, and by the sea – drives its innovative approaches to pressing global challenges.
American Society for the University of Haifa (ASUH)
ASUH is a U.S. nonprofit organization, whose mission is to showcase, celebrate, and raise funds for the programs of the University of Haifa in Israel, serving as a vital connection to the University of Haifa. Institutional partners, individual supporters, university alumni, and U.S. communities each benefit from strengthening relations between the U.S. and the University of Haifa.
Moments of Refuge Project 2020-2030
Moments of Refuge Project is a global science-based initiative applying our mindfulness- and compassion-based intervention model to empower diverse forcibly displaced people to begin to heal and recover, and thereby prevent the destructive long-term consequences of forced displacement for families and communities. Moments is grounded in 3 core beliefs. First, we believe that mental health and the right to recovery following forced displacement is a basic human right that we must guarantee. Second, we believe that mental health is inextricably linked to social justice, equality and mobility. Third, we believe that it is our ethical obligation to act and resist injustice with compassionate action grounded in the strongest science and evidence available to us. We have thus worked for over a decade to bring the most ambitious, rigorous and compassionate science that we can envision to empower and support refugees to heal from the trauma and injustice of forced displacement.
Our work to-date has primarily focused on African asylum-seekers who have sought sanctuary in the Middle East (Israel). Over the coming decade, we aspire to systematically grow and scale-up Moments of Refuge through a network of collaborating scientific, implementation, and refugee community partners. Moments partner sites will reach forcibly displaced communities, from multiple origin countries and socio-cultural groups, multiple post-displacement settings (e.g., urban, refugee camp), and regions around the world including Europe (e.g. Italy, Germany), the Middle East (e.g. Jordan, Turkey), Africa (e.g. S. Africa, Uganda), and N. America (e.g. Texas, Boston). We believe strongly that the scientific foundation and approach to Moments of Refuge is critical to ensure its impact.
Although our team believes that our mindfulness-based intervention model will prove to be a transformative and restorative innovation in refugee global mental health and social justice, our good intentions and even exciting findings to date are not enough. Thus, Moments is designed to allow us to transform the lives of forcibly displaced people, while concurrently rigorously monitoring, evaluating and thereby optimizing the efficacy and safety of our mindfulness-based intervention model as well as its access and reach. We believe that this approach will deliver the greatest possible social impact return on investment.